The Lounge  •  [RANT] MobileMe

[RANT] MobileMe

from San Francisco, CA
1533 posts

I just love how "sync" usually means "MobileMe will randomly pick one for you" when something's changed. Grrrrr.


John Casasanta — MacHeist Director
tap tap tap chief
1
Safe Cracker
from a cliff in the arctic ocean.
2580 posts

Try using Contactizer Pro on two machines, and you'll love even more when MobileMe decides the data on the sync server isn't valid anymore, forcing you to throw all data from one machine, resetting the sync... yikes neutral

I installed GroupOffice the other day, and now I have a good reson to do away with iCal, Mail and Contactizer. *phew!


*Rawwr*
2
Bank Robber
from Houston, TX
654 posts

I decided to cancel my .Mac / Mobile Me after waiting for more "promo" or "exclusive deal" apps that got me hooked in the first place.

For syncing, I'm using Calgoo Connect, so I can still use MenuCalendar iCal when I'm here and  Google Calendar when I'm somewhere else.  Can also be easily shared with other users.

Can't say I've tested it enough to know if it's less buggy or more reliable than MobilMe.

3
from San Francisco, CA
1533 posts

It's especially annoying this time because it "synced" the MacHeist server login with the old one instead of the new one. Wake up Scott...

... and the other day it "synced" my mail settings with all old settings on my laptop when things changed on my iMac.

... and a few days before that it deleted a widget I use on my laptop that I don't use on my iMac.

... and I can't count how many times I've changed a contact's email or phone number, only to see both appear after a "sync".

... and don't let me forget how it slows the system to a crawl when it's going through the motions of syncing. Forget about getting anything done if MobileMe is syncing while Time Machine is backing up.

Yeah, it does work some of the time, but for the most part, it's garbage. Just not up to Apple standards. But then again, Apple's quality just seems to be on a downhill slide lately.

Alright, I'm done ranting. It's just frustrating when you're trying to get work done.


John Casasanta — MacHeist Director
tap tap tap chief
4
from Chicago
5386 posts

I've had issues with MobileMe not syncing but it works fine now for me.  I had to wipe the data on my iPhone, though, but it works now.

5
Jewel Thief
from South Korea
424 posts

I like MobileMe's storage space.  I've got a lot stored on there.

So, yeah.  That's nice


Our ORANGE photo and movie blog in Bucheon, Korea: http://www.eatyourkimchi.com
6
Safe Cracker
from a cliff in the arctic ocean.
2580 posts

Code:

afp_...  411Gi  210Gi  201Gi    52%    /Volumes/user

I like my Linux server better tongue


*Rawwr*
7
Safe Cracker
from coast2coast
1982 posts

johnred wrote:

Alright, I'm done ranting. It's just frustrating when you're trying to get work done.

From what I've read Snow Leopard will add new support for Microsoft's Exchange Server to the push messaging support Apple integrated into iPhone 2.0. That may finally straighten out MobileMe sync.

8
from Fredericton, New Brunswick
3484 posts

Friends don't let friends use Apple web apps.


When the inevitable struggle between Earth and the Pfhor begins, it wont be a one-sided annihilation like it was here a thousand years ago, but a battle to topple an empire.

AppShelf MacHeist Loot Files
AppShelf Files for the nanoBundle
9
Safe Cracker
1691 posts

WhiteFang wrote:

Try using Contactizer Pro on two machines, and you'll love even more when MobileMe decides the data on the sync server isn't valid anymore, forcing you to throw all data from one machine, resetting the sync... yikes neutral

I installed GroupOffice the other day, and now I have a good reson to do away with iCal, Mail and Contactizer. *phew!

Was Contactizer itself giving you trouble? Or was it just Apple's sync feature?


Look Ma, no teeth!
10
Bank Robber
931 posts

mjweb wrote:

From what I've read Snow Leopard will add new support for Microsoft's Exchange Server to the push messaging support Apple integrated into iPhone 2.0. That may finally straighten out MobileMe sync.

Snow Leopard will support Microsoft Exchange for mail, calendaring, etc. This implies that Mail.app will be able to natively talk to Microsoft Exchange provided you use a Microsoft Exchange server for email (like in corporate environments). While this may help MobileMe users who use Microsoft Exchange, it won't help people who do not use Microsoft Exchange (which is the majority of users). Even in the former case, the benefits, if any, would be restricted to the data stored/managed on the Microsoft Exchange side.


Whatever...
11
Safe Cracker
from a cliff in the arctic ocean.
2580 posts

@bob: Just Apple's sync feature. But the problem is of course that I needed the same data on 2+ computers. "The magicks of intertubes and spiderwebs" solved the problem wink


*Rawwr*
12
Safe Cracker
1691 posts

Thanks WhiteFang. I've read many horror stories about Apple's synchronization. I don't use iCal or Address Book, and unfortunately many 3rd party applications love to rely on them.


Look Ma, no teeth!
13
Jewel Thief
381 posts

I wish someone could tell the apple fanboys that infest the apple supprt forums about the declining quality....


Plastic Fish Never Die
14
Safe Cracker
from a cliff in the arctic ocean.
2580 posts

Take it from someone who knows - telling "religious exremeists" that they may be wrong has the opposite effect of what you intended. Regradless of what "religious sect" may be involved...


*Rawwr*
15
Safe Cracker
from Rantoul, Illinois
1222 posts

kongobongo wrote:

I wish someone could tell the apple fanboys that infest the apple supprt forums about the declining quality....

Declining?  I don't use MobileMe but I've kept my eye and ear on it from when Apple first came out with their online syncing solution and I've always heard people complaining about it just as I've heard people brag about it.  I think you hear more about it now mostly as a result of its usage growing.

16
from Chicago
5386 posts

kongobongo wrote:

I wish someone could tell the apple fanboys that infest the apple supprt forums about the declining quality....

Declining quality?  It's only gone up from the launch.  Apple admitted the mistakes of MobileMe and they're doing all they can to correct them.

And to be honest, Activesync and Exchange have just as many problems.  Cloud computing is still a pain.

17
Jewel Thief
from UK
450 posts

I've had PDA's of one guise or another for many years  mostly Psion Organizers, iPaqs etc and every one has caused problems around syncing eventually. 

Syncing seems to be a black art that eventually always seems to get its knickers in a twist. the end result usually being deleted and missing entries or the really annoying duplicate entries.

18
Safe Cracker
from coast2coast
1982 posts

WhiteFang wrote:

Take it from someone who knows - telling "religious exremeists" that they may be wrong has the opposite effect of what you intended. Regradless of what "religious sect" may be involved...

+1 LOL

19
2356 posts

I've never had a single problem w/MobileMe sync - not with bookmarks, contacts, keychains, etc. Nothing. Ever.

20
Safe Cracker
from coast2coast
1982 posts

jpdyson wrote:

I've never had a single problem w/MobileMe sync - not with bookmarks, contacts, keychains, etc. Nothing. Ever.

Are you giving testimony, brother JP? smile

21
2356 posts

mjweb wrote:

jpdyson wrote:

I've never had a single problem w/MobileMe sync - not with bookmarks, contacts, keychains, etc. Nothing. Ever.

Are you giving testimony, brother JP? smile

No, I'm just saying I've not had the problems others have had. It's been good for me.

22
from Malmo, Sweden
194 posts

I've never had any form of syncing ever work correctly. From Palm HotSync up to iSync+.mac. Although TBQH I've never lost anything with .mac syncing, it's just annoyed my with WHICH ONE OF THESE SHOULD I CHOOSE?!?! dialogs. I haven't used it seriously since they rebranded it MobileMe (only one mac now, and my phone syncs to the mac directly with iSync/Bluetooth) so I don't know if things have changed.


Karl Baron 〜 I break things at MacHeist as well but I successfully blame it on Scott
23
from San Francisco, CA
1533 posts

tech wrote:

kongobongo wrote:

I wish someone could tell the apple fanboys that infest the apple supprt forums about the declining quality....

Declining?  I don't use MobileMe but I've kept my eye and ear on it from when Apple first came out with their online syncing solution and I've always heard people complaining about it just as I've heard people brag about it.  I think you hear more about it now mostly as a result of its usage growing.

My original "declining quality" comment had to do with Apple in general lately, rather than MobileMe in particular. Sure, it's debatable but I really feel like Apple is just losing it as far as the care they put into the things they do. I really hope I'm wrong in the long run.


John Casasanta — MacHeist Director
tap tap tap chief
24
from Malmo, Sweden
194 posts

johnred wrote:

My original "declining quality" comment had to do with Apple in general lately, rather than MobileMe in particular. Sure, it's debatable but I really feel like Apple is just losing it as far as the care they put into the things they do. I really hope I'm wrong in the long run.

I don't think they've really declined in quality, it's just our standards have been raised due to the high quality of refinement of Apple's more advanced products. I think you've just forgotten just how crappy OS X 10.0-10.2 were.


Karl Baron 〜 I break things at MacHeist as well but I successfully blame it on Scott
25

Board footer